Savannah vs Hilton Head Island: 7 Key Differences to Know Before Your Coastal Georgia Getaway

Planning a coastal getaway to the southeastern US? You might be torn between the beautiful beach resort of Hilton Head Island and the charming historical city of Savannah. While Savannah offers rich history, lovely squares, and vibrant nightlife, Hilton Head Island is better suited for those seeking beach relaxation, golf courses, and resort amenities—only about 40 minutes apart.

Despite their close proximity, these two destinations offer completely different vacation experiences. Savannah draws visitors with its museums, historical sights, shopping districts, and southern hospitality. Hilton Head Island, on the other hand, caters to beach lovers and golf enthusiasts looking for a more laid-back resort experience.

Many travelers find that combining both locations makes for the perfect vacation. You can base yourself in one place and take a day trip to explore the other, getting the best of both worlds—Savannah’s urban charm and Hilton Head’s coastal beauty.

Geographical Overview

Savannah and Hilton Head Island nestle along the southeastern Atlantic coastline, offering different geographical experiences. Savannah, Georgia, is about 15 miles inland from the Atlantic Ocean on the Savannah River.

The city’s famous historic district spans about 2.5 square miles and features stunning architecture. You’ve probably seen those gorgeous oak trees draped with Spanish moss in photos.

Hilton Head Island, meanwhile, is precisely what it sounds like—an actual island! Located in South Carolina’s Lowcountry region, it’s about 12 miles long and 5 miles wid,e with over 12 miles of pristine Atlantic beaches.

The distance between these two destinations is surprisingly short—only about 30 miles or a 45-minute drive. This proximity makes it possible to base yourself in one location and visit the other on a day trip.

Both areas share similar coastal landscapes typical of the Southeast—marshlands, tidal creeks, and lush greenery. The natural environment around Hilton Head tends to be more preserved and accessible, with numerous wildlife areas and nature preserves.

Savannah’s geographical layout centers around its historic grid pattern of streets and famous squares. The city is at a slightly higher elevation than the ultra-flat Hilton Head.

The two have nearly identical weather patterns, with hot, humid summers and mild winters. Both locations can experience impacts from Atlantic hurricanes, typically between June and November.

Historical Significance

Savannah and Hilton Head Island boast fascinating historical backgrounds that have shaped their current character and appeal. Their stories involve early exploration, pivotal Civil War moments, and distinct cultural developments that visitors can still experience today.

Savannah’s Rich History

Savannah stands as one of America’s best-preserved historical cities. General James Oglethorpe founded it in 1733, making it Georgia’s first city and an important colonial port.

The city’s unique grid layout with 22 historic squares remains largely intact, allowing visitors to step back in time while walking through the Historic District. Many antebellum homes and buildings survived General Sherman’s “March to the Sea” during the Civil War because he was so impressed by the city’s beauty that he spared it.

Savannah’s rich architectural heritage includes Federal, Victorian, and Gothic styles. Visitors can explore museums, historic homes, and landmarks that tell stories of the Revolutionary War, Civil War, and the city’s economic importance.

Hilton Head’s Heritage

Hilton Head Island has a diverse historical timeline, starting in 1526, when Spanish explorers first documented the area and named it “La Flori.” The island remained largely undeveloped until the mid-20th century.

During the Civil War, Hilton Head served as a crucial Union base of operations for blockading Southern ports. After Union forces captured the island in 1861, it became one of the earliest places in the South where formerly enslaved people created self-governed communities.

The Gullah Geechee culture—descendants of enslaved West Africans—continues to influence the island’s cultural heritage. Their unique language, crafts, and traditions are essential to Hilton Head’s identity. The island’s modern development as a resort destination began in the 1950s, carefully planned to preserve natural areas alongside recreational facilities.

Attractions and Activities

Both destinations offer unique experiences for travelers. Savannah draws visitors with its historic district and guided tours, while Hilton Head Island appeals to those seeking beaches and outdoor recreation.

Savannah’s Landmarks and Tours

Savannah’s Historic District is the city’s heart with its 22 beautiful squares, historic homes, and moss-draped oak trees. Visitors can explore iconic landmarks like Forsyth Park’s famous fountain and the Gothic-revival Cathedral of St. John the Baptist.

Many travelers enjoy guided walking tours that delve into the city’s rich history and ghostly legends. The riverfront area on River Street offers cobblestone streets lined with shops, restaurants, and views of massive cargo ships.

Downtown Savannah is highly walkable, but trolley tours provide an excellent overview for first-time visitors. Tybee Island is just 20 minutes away for beach lovers and offers a more relaxed coastal experience with its lighthouse and expansive beaches.

Hilton Head’s Beaches and Nature

Hilton Head Island is renowned for its 12 miles of pristine beaches. Coligny Beach Park is particularly popular because it offers amenities like showers, changing rooms, and nearby shopping.

Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the island’s commitment to preservation. The 605-acre Sea Pines Forest Preserve offers walking trails through undisturbed maritime forest and marshlands. Visitors can spot alligators, birds, and other wildlife in their natural habitats.

Boating is a major attraction on Hilton Head. Visitors can book dolphin-watching cruises or rent kayaks to explore the island’s waterways.

The island also features over 60 miles of bicycle paths, making cycling popular. Hilton Head boasts over 20 championship courses for golf enthusiasts, including the famous Harbour Town Golf Links, home to the PGA Tour’s RBC Heritage tournament.

See Related: Savannah vs Charleston: Key Differences to Know Before Your Southern Getaway

Cuisine and Dining

Both destinations offer distinctive culinary experiences that reflect their coastal locations and Southern heritage. Food lovers will find plenty to enjoy in each place, though the dining atmospheres differ significantly.

Savannah’s Culinary Scene

Savannah’s food scene blends traditional Southern cooking with modern culinary trends. The historic district features restaurants in beautiful old buildings where you can sample classics like shrimp and grits, fried green tomatoes, and peach cobbler.

Mrs. Wilkes Dining Room offers a legendary family-style Southern dining experience, though be prepared to wait in line. The city also boasts excellent seafood restaurants where fresh catch from nearby waters takes center stage.

For a truly local experience, don’t miss the pralines—sweet candy confections that vendors sell throughout the historic district. The city’s open container laws also allow you to grab a drink while exploring the beautiful squares. Savannah’s food scene tends to be more diverse than Hilton Head’s, with a wider variety of international cuisines represented.

Hilton Head’s Seafood Delights

Hilton Head Island specializes in fresh seafood and waterfront dining. The island’s restaurants frequently feature locally caught shrimp, oysters, and fish in various styles.

Skull Creek Boathouse is a popular dining spot where you can enjoy seafood while watching boats pass by. However, as the search results mention, waterfront restaurants often have long waits during summer, so plan accordingly.

Many restaurants on Hilton Head offer stunning marsh or ocean views, creating a relaxed vacation atmosphere. The island also features several upscale dining options at resorts and golf clubs.

Prices at Hilton Head restaurants tend to be higher than those in Savannah. The search results note that the average daily cost in Hilton Head is $287 compared to $202 in Savannah.

This difference reflects the island’s status as a premium vacation destination. For breakfast, check out local cafés serving fresh pastries and coffee—perfect fuel before a day at the beach.

Shopping Experiences

Savannah and Hilton Head Island offer unique shopping opportunities for different tastes and preferences. Savannah shines with its historic boutiques and artisan shops, while Hilton Head provides a mix of upscale retail and island-themed stores.

Boutiques in Savannah

Savannah’s shopping scene is truly special, centered around the Historic District and River Street. These charming areas are filled with unique boutiques housed in historic buildings that add character to your shopping experience.

Broughton Street is a must-visit for fashion lovers. Here you’ll find a mix of well-known brands alongside local designers and vintage shops. The Paris Market & Brocante is a favorite spot, offering an eclectic collection of home goods, jewelry, and gifts worldwide.

For art enthusiasts, the City Market area showcases galleries and studios where you can often watch artists at work. Many shops offer one-of-a-kind crafts and SCAD (Savannah College of Art and Design) student creations that make perfect souvenirs.

Shops of Hilton Head

Hilton Head Island offers a more relaxed shopping experience, with several outdoor shopping centers and village-style complexes. Shelter Cove Towne Centre is popular among visitors, and visitors can enjoy waterfront views while browsing upscale boutiques and specialty stores.

Coligny Plaza is the island’s original shopping center, home to over 60 shops and restaurants. Its casual, beachy atmosphere makes it perfect for picking up island-themed souvenirs, resort wear, and casual clothing.

For luxury shoppers, The Shops at Sea Pines Center provides upscale options in a beautiful setting. Many visitors enjoy exploring Harbour Town, where boutiques sell everything from designer clothing to local art and crafts.

Hilton Head also features several farmers’ markets where you can find fresh local foods, handmade products, and unique gifts from island artisans.

Accommodations and Lodging

Where you choose to stay can significantly affect your vacation experience. Savannah offers historic charm with boutique hotels and B&Bs, while Hilton Head features upscale resorts with beach access and amenities.

Staying in Historic Savannah

Savannah’s accommodation options capture the city’s Southern charm and rich history. The historic district features beautiful boutique hotels housed in restored buildings that date back centuries. Many offer gorgeous courtyards, antique furnishings, and walking distance to major attractions.

Bed and breakfasts are particularly popular in Savannah. These intimate lodgings often include homemade Southern breakfasts and afternoon tea. Prices in Savannah tend to be more affordable than in Hilton Head, with average daily costs around $202 per person.

For budget travelers, several chain hotels are located just outside the historic district. These provide good value while still being a short drive from Savannah’s famous squares and restaurants.

Resorts in Hilton Head

Hilton Head Island specializes in upscale resort experiences with beachfront properties dominating the accommodation landscape. Many resorts offer direct beach access, multiple swimming pools, and on-site golf courses or tennis facilities.

Vacation rentals are abundant on Hilton Head Island, with condos and beach houses perfect for families or larger groups. These often include full kitchens and living spaces that provide a home-away-from-home feel.

Be prepared for higher prices on the island, with daily costs averaging around $287 per person. Rates climb even higher during the peak summer season as beach-seekers flock to the island.

Most accommodations on Hilton Head are clustered within planned communities or “plantations” that include security gates and pristine landscaping. These communities often have their restaurants, shops, and recreational facilities.

Best Times to Visit

Spring and fall are the perfect times to visit Savannah and Hilton Head Island. These shoulder seasons offer pleasant weather and fewer crowds.

In Savannah, temperatures range between the high 50s and mid-80s from March through June. In spring, the city comes alive with blooming azaleas and dogwoods, making it especially charming for walking tours.

For Hilton Head Island, April and May stand out as ideal months. The beaches aren’t crowded yet; you’ll enjoy warm days perfect for golf and outdoor activities.

September and October are fantastic for both destinations. The Atlantic waters at Hilton Head remain warm enough for swimming, while the summer humidity in Savannah begins to fade.

Travelers should note that summer (June-August) brings the highest temperatures and biggest crowds to both places. Hotel rates also peak during this time.

Winter offers the lowest prices and fewest tourists, though temperatures can dip into the 40s. Many outdoor activities remain possible, but beach time will be limited.

Here’s a quick comparison:

Season	Savannah	Hilton Head Island
Spring	Excellent weather, beautiful blooms	Perfect beach days beginning
Summer	Hot and humid, busy	Crowded beaches, peak prices
Fall	Mild temps, fewer tourists	Warm ocean, smaller crowds
Winter	Chilly but affordable	Quiet, focus on non-beach activities

A good strategy might be spending 1-3 days in Savannah and 5-7 days in Hilton Head for a complete coastal experience.

See Related: Savannah vs Tybee Island: Key Differences to Know Before Your Georgia Coastal Getaway

Travel Tips and Considerations

Planning your visit to either Savannah or Hilton Head requires practical knowledge about getting around and staying safe. Both destinations offer unique experiences, but have different transportation options and safety considerations.

Transportation and Getting Around

Savannah’s historic district is extremely walkable, with its grid layout and beautiful squares making it perfect for exploring on foot. If you get tired, the free DOT shuttle connects major downtown sites. Renting a car isn’t necessary if you’re staying downtown, though it’s helpful if you want to visit Tybee Island (about 20 minutes away).

Hilton Head Island, on the other hand, almost requires a car. The island is spread out, and while there are bike paths everywhere (over 60 miles!), distances between attractions can be significant. Rental cars are available at the Savannah airport.

If visiting both places, consider:

• Staying in one location and making day trips (they’re about 45 minutes apart)
• Using rideshare services like Uber or Lyft for short trips
• Renting bikes in Hilton Head (a local favorite way to get around)

Safety and Accessibility

Both destinations are generally safe for tourists, but normal precautions apply. Savannah’s historic district is well-patrolled but can get lively at night, especially on weekends. Stick to well-lit areas after dark and be mindful of your belongings.

Hilton Head Island’s beaches have excellent accessibility features, with beach wheelchairs available for free at most public beach access points. The island’s flat terrain also makes it ideal for travelers with mobility issues.

Weather considerations affect both locations similarly. Hurricane season (June-November) can disrupt travel plans, so trip insurance is wise during these months. Summer brings intense heat and humidity, while spring and fall offer milder temperatures for sightseeing.

Both places have good medical facilities, though Savannah offers more comprehensive healthcare services at larger hospitals if that’s a concern.

Comparative Summary

Several key differences stand out when looking at Savannah, Georgia, versus Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.

Cost of Living

Aspect	Savannah	Hilton Head Island
Housing	Lower	178.8% more expensive
Overall	More affordable	36.1% more expensive

Hilton Head Island offers a more relaxed, beach-focused experience. Its vibe caters to those seeking quiet relaxation, and there are plenty of beaches for lounging and water activities.

Conversely, Savannah provides a richer urban experience with historic architecture, vibrant nightlife, and cultural attractions. The city’s walkable historic district makes it ideal for sightseeing and exploring.

Distance-wise, the two destinations are only about an hour apart. This makes them perfect for combination trips, allowing visitors to experience both locations during one vacation.

For those considering relocation, the salary requirements differ significantly. According to the search results, you’d need a salary of $272,172 in Hilton Head Island to maintain the same lifestyle that would cost you $200,000 in Savannah.

Commute times also factor into quality of life. The search results suggest differences in commute times between the two locations, though specific details aren’t provided.

For travelers, Hilton Head Island is a convenient beach option when you don’t want to drive to the Savannah city center. This proximity creates flexibility for day trips in either direction.

See Related: Savannah vs Brunswick: Key Differences Between Georgia’s Historic Coastal Cities

Frequently Asked Questions

Travelers choosing between Savannah and Hilton Head Island often have specific questions about what makes each destination unique. These two coastal gems offer distinct experiences despite being just 40 minutes apart.

Book Your Dream Experience

More Travel Guides