The Creole Creamery | Bay St. Louis, MS 39520

## Creole Creamery (Bay St. Louis): what to order, when to go, and how to make it worth the stop

If you’re wandering Old Town Bay St. Louis and want a dessert stop that feels like a destination (not an afterthought), The Creole Creamery is an easy yes. The Bay St. Louis shop is at 209 Main Street, Bay St Louis, MS 39520, with the posted phone number (228) 231-1943. Creole Creamery

This is part of the broader Creole Creamery family of shops, and the official site lists Bay St. Louis as one of its locations. Creole Creamery

—

## Quick essentials (so you don’t have to hunt)

– Address: 209 Main Street, Bay St Louis, MS 39520 Creole Creamery
– Phone: (228) 231-1943 Creole Creamery
– Hours (as listed on Creole Creamery’s official site):
– Sun–Thu: noon–9pm
– Fri–Sat: noon–10pm Creole Creamery
– Positioning: Coastal Mississippi describes it as the first franchised Creole Creamery placed in the heart of Old Town Bay St Louis. Mississippi

### Outdated-data flag
Hours, seasonal closures, and flavor availability can change fast—especially on the coast. Treat the hours above as “last known from the official site,” and verify day-of on Creole Creamery’s locations page or the shop’s social updates. Creole Creamery

—

## What kind of place is it?

Creole Creamery’s brand is built around gourmet ice cream with a big flavor bench and a menu that goes beyond basic scoops. Their official site emphasizes core categories like ice cream menu items, plus birthday parties, gift cards, catering, and other event-friendly options. Creole Creamery

For Bay St. Louis specifically, local destination listings also frame it as a sweet-treat stop in Old Town—helpful context if you’re planning a walking afternoon around shops and galleries. Mississippi

—

## What to order: a smart way to choose (especially if you hate decision fatigue)

### 1) Start with a “signature-style” menu item if you want the full experience
If you’re the kind of traveler who prefers one photogenic, composed dessert rather than two random scoops, Creole Creamery’s menu highlights plated/assembled items like:

– I Scream Fudge! (two scoops served in a fudge-coated glass with chocolate chips, whipped cream, cocoa powder, and a cherry) Creole Creamery
– Creole Strawberry (fresh strawberries over creole cream cheese ice cream, topped with whipped cream, a cherry, and a wafer) Creole Creamery
– Fudge Brownie à la Mode (vanilla ice cream and fudge over a warm brownie, topped with whipped cream) Creole Creamery

These are useful “default orders” when you’re visiting for the first time, because they give you a clear baseline for texture (creaminess), mix-ins, and portion size.

### 2) If you’re chasing unusual flavors, scan for the standouts
The official flavors list includes options like Ube and Thai Basil Coconut—both good signals that the shop leans into bolder, ingredient-forward flavors rather than only classics. Creole Creamery

Practical move: pick one adventurous flavor (like Ube or Thai Basil Coconut) and one familiar anchor flavor. That way, even if the wild card isn’t your personal favorite, you still leave happy.

### 3) Dairy-free / vegan: what you can confidently expect
Creole Creamery has publicly promoted vegan ice cream made with coconut cream. That’s useful if you’re dairy-free, lactose intolerant, or traveling with someone who is—because coconut-cream bases often keep a rich mouthfeel compared to many sorbets.

Inclusivity note: “Vegan” can still involve cross-contact risk in shared scoop environments. If allergies are serious, call ahead and ask how they handle allergens and dedicated utensils. (That’s not a knock—just the reality of most ice-cream counters.)

—

## Best time to go (based on posted hours)

Because Bay St. Louis hours are listed as opening at noon, this is naturally a midday-to-evening stop, not a morning coffee-and-pastry place. Creole Creamery

If you want the calmest experience, going earlier in the afternoon gives you more time to ask about flavors, sample thoughtfully (if offered), and actually taste what you ordered rather than speed-eating in a line.

—

## Make it part of a Bay St. Louis “Old Town” mini-plan

Coastal Mississippi positions the shop in the heart of Old Town Bay St Louis, which makes it a logical “reward stop” after browsing Main Street. Mississippi

A simple structure that works:
– Explore Old Town on foot.
– Pick your ice cream stop as the midpoint break.
– End with a second loop if you’re staying nearby (ice cream is a surprisingly good pacing tool).

—

## Two contextual internal link opportunities (for RealJourneyTravels editors)

If these pages exist (or you plan to publish them), they’ll fit naturally inside this article:

1) Anchor: Best things to do in Bay St. Louis (Old Town walking loop)
Where to place: right after the “Old Town mini-plan” section.

2) Anchor: Mississippi Gulf Coast road trip stops (food + dessert)
Where to place: near the end as a “keep exploring” segue.

—

## Bottom line

Creole Creamery in Bay St. Louis is a strong pick when you want Mississippi Gulf Coast dessert that feels intentional: a real menu, notable flavors like Ube and Thai Basil Coconut, and documented options for coconut-cream vegan ice cream—all in a walkable Old Town setting. Creole Creamery

Just verify hours day-of (seasonality happens), then order one signature-style dessert or one bold flavor + one classic and call it a win. Creole Creamery